Methodology

Why the price and the value disagree

When StockValuer's estimate and the market price differ, ask what the price assumes and whether that is plausible. This guide shows how.

Two numbers that differ

A company page shows two numbers side by side: the market price, and the value StockValuer's model computes for the business. They usually differ, and the first question most people ask is which one is wrong.

Nobody can answer that. A more useful question can be answered: what would you have to believe for today's price to be correct?

Running the model backwards

A DCF turns assumptions into a value. You can also run it in reverse to turn a value into assumptions. Hold every input steady except one, and solve for the value of that input that makes the model produce exactly the market price.

Solve for revenue growth and you get a statement like “the market is pricing this as if revenue grows 11% a year”. This is arithmetic, not a survey of what investors think. It is the growth rate that reconciles the price with the rest of the model.

The implied rate needs a comparison

Some growth rate always reproduces a given price. So a statement like “the market implies 11%” can be made about every company at every price, and on its own it tells you nothing.

It becomes useful when you compare it with something. StockValuer compares the implied rate with what the company has actually delivered: its revenue growth over the last five years, computed from the filings it already ingests. Both ends of that period use trailing twelve months, so seasonality cannot distort the result.

For example, suppose the market implies 11% and the company has grown 24% a year for five years. Either the market expects a sharp slowdown, or it is mispricing the business. That is worth looking into. StockValuer does not say which of the two it is.

Slowing down is normal

Before you read much into a gap, remember that growth rates almost always fall over time. Nobody expects a company growing 40% a year to keep that up. A market pricing it at 30% is doing ordinary arithmetic about a business getting larger. That is not a sign of mispricing.

So StockValuer only describes an implied rate as below or above the record when it is well outside what normal slowing explains. Otherwise every good company would be flagged as mispriced, and the flag would tell you nothing.

More than one input can explain a price

The reverse solve has a second limit. Solving for growth holds margins, the discount rate and everything else fixed. If you hold growth fixed and solve for margin instead, you get a different explanation of the same price that is just as valid.

So the page shows both. The price might fit 11% growth at today's margins, or today's growth at a much lower margin, or many combinations in between. A single price cannot tell you what the market actually believes. Treat any one solved figure as one possible reading of the price, and not as “the market's view”.

Parts of a gap that are not disagreement

Some of the distance between price and value is not a difference of opinion. Before you weigh the rest, set these aside:

  • Timing: StockValuer's figures are struck on a filing date, and the price moves every day. Part of a gap can be what happened since.
  • Model uncertainty: every valuation has a robustness check. If the value swings hard with terminal growth, part of the gap is the model's own margin of error.
  • What the model cannot see: continued dilution, guidance that has been unreliable in the past, events recorded since the run, or past growth that came from acquisitions instead of from the business itself.

Why StockValuer does not call a stock mispriced

StockValuer never says the market is wrong. This is deliberate.

A valuation is useful because you can see every assumption, disagree with any of them, and reach your own conclusion. That is why you can change the judgments behind every value here: the growth, margins and risk. A verdict from the tool would replace your own judgment.

StockValuer can tell you what the price assumes and how that compares with the company's record. It cannot tell you whether the market knows something the model does not.