Methodology

Keeping several portfolios, and moving shares between them

A Pro account can keep more than one portfolio, see one company's position across all of them on its Portfolio tab, and move shares from one portfolio to another without a sale.

One portfolio, or several

A free account has one portfolio, and everything on the Portfolio page is about it. A Pro account can make more, up to 20 in all, for example one for each brokerage account, or one for each purpose. Above the holdings, the Portfolio page then shows a row with each portfolio and All portfolios. Choose one and the holdings, the summary, the returns report, the downloads, Import CSV and Add entry are all about that portfolio; choose All portfolios to see them added together.

Choose Manage to make a portfolio, rename one or delete one. The first portfolio cannot be deleted, only renamed. A portfolio can be deleted once it holds nothing: its own entries are deleted with it, and shares that were moved out of it keep their dates and cost in the portfolio they went to. If you go back to a free account, you keep the portfolios you made and can still add entries to them; you cannot make a new one or move shares.

The free limit of 10 open holdings counts companies across all of your portfolios together, so holding the same company in two portfolios is one holding.

The Portfolio tab on a company page

Every company page has a Portfolio tab, after Financials. It is only about that one company: the shares you hold across all your portfolios, the average cost (or the cost a share under FIFO), what it is worth at the latest price, and the gain, then a row for each portfolio that holds it with the same four figures, and every entry you have made in it. Choose Add trade to record a buy, a sale, a dividend or a split in the portfolio you pick. Open full portfolio leads to the Portfolio page.

Signed out, the tab says what it is for and offers to sign you in. On a free account it shows your one portfolio, and says that several portfolios and moving shares between them are part of Pro. Like the Portfolio page, it is only for you: it shows no company logo, and nothing on it is kept in the browser or put in the address.

Moving shares between portfolios

StockValuer does not connect to brokers, so it only knows what you tell it. If you moved shares between two accounts, or want to split one holding between portfolios, record it here with Move shares on the company's Portfolio tab. Choose the portfolio the shares leave, the portfolio they go to and the date, then either how many shares, taken from the oldest lots first, or Choose lots to move whole lots.

A move is not a sale. The lots arrive with the date they were bought and what they cost, so no gain is realised, and the shares and cost across all your portfolios are the same as before. Within one portfolio, FIFO then counts those lots as the oldest, in the order they were bought. The average cost moves with the shares too, so it changes in each portfolio, but not across them.

Each portfolio's history shows the move as a line such as “Moved 10 shares from Brokerage to Retirement”. Choose Undo on the line to take it back: the shares go back to the portfolio they left, as they were. It is refused while a later entry depends on it, such as a sale in the portfolio they went to of shares that came with the move; change or delete that entry first.

A stock split applies to every portfolio that held the shares, and a split StockValuer detected is applied to a holding across all of them, so a move before or after it keeps the shares and the cost right. A holding with a trade inside a split's range still says “Check this” whichever portfolio the trade is in.

What it is not

A portfolio here is a record you keep, set against the researched base case. It is not a broker account, it does not place or move anything, and it is not a tax record: how a transfer between accounts is treated for tax depends on the accounts, and is not something StockValuer works out.