AUTONATION, INC.

NYSE: AN·Fort Lauderdale, Florida·

Price
$178.07
Base IV
$247.11

Valuation snapshot

Below base case

At $178.07, the price sits between our bear case ($81.58) and base case ($247.11).

Values per share, from an .

No growth
…
Loading earnings power
Base case
$247.11
above today's price · range $81.58–$429.88
Price vs base case
28% below
$178.07 against $247.11
Base casevalued by DCF
Price vs base
Priceclose 11‑16

The price has fallen 3.3% since this valuation was struck on 2026-11-11, so some of the gap opened up after these figures were set.

Whisker on the base case runs bear $81.58 to bull $429.88. Values per share.

Price against each value

Bear case
$81.58
Price 118% above
No growth
…
—
Base case
$247.11
Price 28% below
Researched bygpt-6.1-sol
Valuation Nov 11, 2026 · Price as of Nov 16, 2026How we got here

What does Autonation do?

AutoNation sells new and used vehicles, automotive parts, and repair services while providing financing and insurance products to retail consumers.

It brought in $27.4B of sales in the 12 months to Sep 2026.

Led by Michael Manley, Chief Executive Officer and Director since 2021. AutoNation Board of Directors

New vehicle sales at a franchised dealership.Michael Sheehan, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Industry
Consumer discretionary
Based in
Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Trades on
NYSE as AN

Here is where each dollar a customer pays ends up. Out of every $1 of sales in the 12 months to Sep 2026, about 3¢ was left as profit after every cost, interest and tax. The biggest cost is making what it sells, 82¢ of every dollar.

  • Making what it sells82¢
  • Sales, marketing and admin12¢
  • Everything else it takes to operate1¢
  • Interest and other costs1¢
  • Tax1¢
  • Left as profit3¢
Totals of the four quarters to Sep 2026, from the company's own filings. The split by product is from the latest fiscal year.

Who pays Autonation, and for what?

AutoNation is one of America's largest automotive retailers, selling new and used vehicles through dealership stores across the country. It also generates revenue by providing vehicle maintenance, repair, and collision services, selling replacement parts, and arranging auto loans and protection products.

The company primarily serves individual retail consumers buying or servicing vehicles, as well as collision repair shops and independent mechanics purchasing wholesale automotive parts.

  • New vehicle

    49%

    Sales of new passenger cars, sport utility vehicles, and trucks across 30 automotive brands at franchised dealerships.

    New vehicle sales at a franchised dealership.Michael Sheehan, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Used vehicle

    28%

    Sales of pre-owned cars and trucks to retail consumers and wholesale buyers through dealerships, dedicated stores, and auctions.

  • Parts and service

    17%

    Vehicle repair and routine maintenance, manufacturer warranty and recall work, collision repairs, and wholesale replacement parts.

  • Finance and insurance, net

    5%

    Commissions from arranging customer vehicle loans and leases with third-party lenders, plus sales of vehicle service contracts and protection plans.

Share of the latest fiscal year's sales, as the company reports it.

Where its work physically happens, beyond headquarters:

  • AutoNation Finance (formerly CIG Financial) office — Irvine, United States. Irvine was the headquarters of CIG Financial when AutoNation agreed to buy it in 2022; the business is now the captive lender behind the AutoNation Finance reportable segment, though the current office location could not be confirmed in a recent filing.
  • AutoNation Orlando Auto Auction — Orlando, United States. Opened in 2017 as one of AutoNation's branded wholesale auctions (four operating at year-end 2025, per the FY2025 10-K, which does not name their cities), it gives the company a remarketing channel for used vehicles in Florida, one of its core store markets.
  • AutoNation Houston Auto Auction — Houston, United States. Opened in 2017 as one of AutoNation's branded wholesale auctions (four operating at year-end 2025, per the FY2025 10-K, which does not name their cities), it gives the company a remarketing channel for used vehicles in Texas, one of its core store markets.
See them on the globe

AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

How is the business doing?

Sales grew from $20.4B in 2020 to $27.6B in 2025, about 6% a year.

Running the business leaves about 5¢ of each sales dollar as operating profit, about the same as 3¢ in 2020.

After paying for its upkeep and new investment, it had $22.9M of cash to spare in the 12 months to Sep 2026.

Sales$27.6B
20162025
Operating margin4%
20162025
Free cash flow-$197.5M
20162025
Each bar is one fiscal year (2016–2025), summed from four published quarters; the latest is highlighted.

What does management say it's aiming for?

AutoNation exists to deliver a peerless customer experience and serve as America's best destination to buy and service cars and trucks.

“To deliver a peerless customer experience.”

AutoNation Corporate Profile

Who is responsible for the plan?

Roles checked November 6, 2026.

What management says it is working on now:

  • Expanding Parts and Service Operations

    Management is growing its higher-margin maintenance, repair, and collision network to drive recurring business that remains steady across economic cycles.

    AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K
  • Scaling AutoNation Finance

    The company is expanding its captive finance arm to provide auto loans directly to buyers, creating steady interest income across the vehicle lifecycle.

    AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K
  • Strengthening Omnichannel Shopping

    AutoNation is investing in digital tools so customers can seamlessly browse inventory, value trade-ins, set up financing, and book service online or in store.

    AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K
  • Maximizing Cost and Operational Efficiency

    The company leverages its nationwide scale to centralize administrative tasks, streamline inventory management, and lower purchasing costs.

    AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K
  • Disciplined Capital Allocation

    Management focuses on maintaining modern facilities, pursuing strategic acquisitions, and returning cash to shareholders through share buybacks.

    AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K
Adjusted free cash flow, full-year 2026
$965 million
AutoNation Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript
Capital expenditures, full-year 2026
$280 million to $290 million
AutoNation Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript
SG&A as a percentage of gross profit, by year-end 2026
66% to 67%
AutoNation Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript
AutoNation Finance operating cash flow, full-year 2026
$120 million
AutoNation Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript
AutoNation Finance operating cash flow, by 2027
at least $150 million
AutoNation Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript
Goals in management's own numbers. A target is a promise, not a result.

What's changing right now?

Growth is holding steady. In Q3 2026 it sold 0% less than a year earlier. The year before, quarters averaged 0%.

Its operating margin is about where it was a year ago, 4¢ per sales dollar.

Since Nov 2026 the share price has fallen 4%, from $185.78 to $178.07.

Bull $429.88Base $247.11Bear $81.58Nov 3Nov 16 · $178.07
Daily closing prices we have recorded, set against our bear-to-bull range. Our price records start November 3, 2026.

Recently

Coming up

  • November 15, 2027

    Senior Notes Debt Maturity

    AutoNation has $300 million of 3.8% senior unsecured notes due for repayment or refinancing under prevailing interest rates.

    AutoNation 2025 Form 10-K
  • 2026-2027

    Execution of $1 Billion Share Repurchase Program

    The Board authorized an additional $1 billion share buyback to opportunistically repurchase common stock and reduce shares outstanding.

    AutoNation Q3 2026 Form 10-Q
  • Matures September 14, 2031

    Extended Revolving Credit Facility

    AutoNation amended and expanded its unsecured credit facility to $2.0 billion, securing operational liquidity and borrowing flexibility.

    AutoNation Q3 2026 Form 10-Q
  • Full-Year 2027

    AutoNation Finance Cash Flow Milestone

    Management anticipates its captive finance arm will scale to generate at least $150 million in annual operating cash flow.

    AutoNation Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript

Our own estimate moved too: the base case went from $198.99 to $247.11 a share between our last two valuations. The biggest reason: Parts and service gross profit, quarterly moved from an unreported prior value to $616.6M, as reported in AutoNation Q3 2026 Form 10-Q, parts and service.

What could go wrong?

No business is a sure thing. These are the risks we found, starting with the ones the company itself names. Where a risk would change part of the valuation, it says which.

  1. Vehicle Affordability and Tariffs

    Elevated borrowing rates, general inflation, and import tariffs on vehicles and parts can increase prices and dampen consumer vehicle demand.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growAutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

  2. Dependence on Major Automakers

    AutoNation relies on eight major automaker groups for roughly 89% of new vehicle sales, making results vulnerable to manufacturer supply cuts or brand issues.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsAutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

  3. Information Technology and Cyber Disruption

    Core dealership operations rely on third-party software providers, where cyber incidents or system outages can halt vehicle sales and repair operations.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsAutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

  4. Credit Losses on Auto Loans

    Expanding captive auto lending exposes the company to financial losses if borrowers face economic distress and default on their vehicle loan payments.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsAutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

  5. Complex Regulatory Compliance

    Dealership sales, financing terms, and lending practices are heavily regulated by state and federal agencies, risking fines or operational limits if rules are breached.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsAutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

  6. Intense Industry Competition

    AutoNation faces strong competition from thousands of local franchised dealers, independent used car sellers, and online vehicle sales platforms.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growAutoNation 2025 Form 10-K

  7. Q3 same-store revenue declined despite acquisition support.

    From our researchWould hit how fast sales growAutoNation Q3 2026 earnings release

  8. Q2 adjusted operating income declined year over year.

    From our researchWould hit how much of each sale it keepsAutoNation Q2 2026 earnings release

Is it a good business?

From 2016 to 2025 it earned between 9% and 27% on the capital invested in it, a median of 14%. Its cost of capital in the latest valuation is 7.1%; returns were above it in every one of the 10 years.

From 2016 to 2025 it earned between 12% and 67% on its shareholders' equity, a median of 23%.

Over 10 years its operating margin ranged from 3¢ to 8¢ per sales dollar, a median of 4¢. Gross margin ran from 15¢ to 20¢.

derived computed from the filingsassumption cost of capital from the latest valuation
Return on invested capital15%
20162025

Cost of capital 7.1%

Return on equity28%
20162025
Return on invested capital is operating profit after tax (at the median effective rate, 25%) over debt plus equity less cash at each fiscal year end. Return on equity is net income over equity. Both are computed from published quarters.

It bought back shares: the count fell 12.6% in a year, so each remaining share owns a slightly bigger slice.

What might it be worth?

The Valuation snapshot at the top of this page shows the answer. This is how we got there. A share is a slice of the business, so what a share is worth depends on what the business can earn for its owners from here on. We estimate that three ways, from cautious to hopeful, and call the result .

Today a share costs $178.07. Our put its value between $81.58 and $429.88, with $247.11 in the middle. Underneath sit two simpler checks: what it would cost to rebuild the business, its , and what today's profit is worth with no growth at all, its .

Bear case, $81.58

Recent sales weakness continues, repairs provide only partial relief, and the business keeps less profit from each sale.

Base case, $247.11

Recent sales declines settle down, and steady repair demand helps the business return to modest growth with similar profitability.

Bull case, $429.88

The recent slowdown gives way to stronger car sales, while repairs and customer financing help the business earn more from its existing stores.

Another way in: instead of asking what the business is worth, ask what today's price assumes it will do.

Why the gap?

The price expects less than we do.Margin of safety: 28%

At today's $178.07, the price makes sense if sales shrink about 2.8% a year. We assume they grow 1.9%. Over the last 5 years, sales grew 1.8% a year.

−4%−3%−2%−1%0%+1%+2%+3%Price needs −2.8%Past 5 yrs 1.8%We assume 1.9%

Or, if sales grow 1.9% as we assume, the price works with a profit margin of 3.9% (we assume 4.8%).

Keep in mind: a low price can mean investors see a risk that isn't in the filings yet. Check the Full research tab for what could go wrong.

Do you think sales will shrink?

Try your own numbers

We're moderately sure of this range: it scores 56 out of 100 on our checks. The weakest point is terminal-value dependency.

Test the assumptions

Our base value of $247.11 rests on three assumptions. Change any of them to see how the value per share responds.

  • Revenue growth, 5-year average1.9%
  • Operating margin4.8%
  • Long-term growth rate2.3%

This is an educational explanation built from public filings and our own research, not investment advice. It does not tell you whether to buy or sell anything.

Base estimate

$247.11 38.8%

Build