CASEYS GENERAL STORES INC
Nasdaq: CASY·Ankeny, Iowa·CIK 0000726958
- Price
- $705.72
- Base IV
- $208.90
Valuation snapshot
At $705.72, the price is above even our bull case of $349.65.
Values per share, from an .
- No growth
- …
- Loading earnings power
- Base case
- $208.90
- 30% of the price · range $73.95–$349.65
- Price vs base case
- 238% above
- $705.72 against $208.90
- Base case · our researched forecast, 2026-11-11See the research ↗
- Price vs base · derived: price − base caseWhat the price expects ↗
- Price · StockValuer price feed, 2026-11-16 closeno link today
Whisker on the base case runs bear $73.95 to bull $349.65. Values per share.
Price against each value
- Bear case
- $73.95
- Price 854% above
- No growth
- …
- —
- Base case
- $208.90
- Price 238% above
What does Caseys General Stores do?
Casey's General Stores provides fuel, prepared foods, groceries, and household essentials to consumers through a network of convenience stores and distribution centers.
It brought in $18.7B of sales in the 12 months to Jul 2026.
Led by Darren M. Rebelez, President and Chief Executive Officer since 2019. Casey’s 2026 Form 10-K — Segment Reporting and Signatures
- Industry
- Consumer discretionary
- Based in
- Ankeny, Iowa
- Trades on
- Nasdaq as CASY
Here is where each dollar a customer pays ends up. Out of every $1 of sales in the 12 months to Jul 2026, about 4¢ was left as profit after every cost, interest and tax. The biggest cost is all its costs, 95¢ of every dollar.
- All its costs95¢
- Tax1¢
- Left as profit4¢
Who pays Caseys General Stores, and for what?
Casey’s operates convenience stores, primarily in the Midwest, selling fuel and a wide range of food and everyday items. It also earns revenue from wholesale fuel sales and services such as car washes.
Consumers buy fuel, prepared food, drinks, groceries and other items at its stores; independent dealers and other wholesale customers buy fuel through its wholesale network.
Fuel
60%Retail motor fuel sold at nearly all stores.
Casey's fuel station exteriorTony Webster, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons Grocery and general merchandise
26%Packaged foods, drinks, tobacco and nicotine products, health and beauty items, automotive products and other goods.
Packaged snacks and food counter inside a Casey's storeHarrison Keely, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons Prepared food and dispensed beverages
10%Pizza, sandwiches, bakery items, chicken wings and dispensed drinks.
Other
3%Primarily wholesale fuel and car wash revenue, as well as lottery revenue.
Where its work physically happens, beyond headquarters:
- Terre Haute Distribution Center — Terre Haute, United States. This 340,000-square-foot center distributes merchandise and food products to Casey’s stores and supports its company-operated delivery fleet.
- Joplin Distribution Center — Joplin, United States. This 300,000-square-foot center supplies Casey’s stores and extends the reach of its distribution network.
- Waco Fuel Terminal — Waco, United States. The company-owned fuel terminal supports Casey’s fuel distribution and its acquired wholesale fuel operations.
How is the business doing?
Sales grew from $8.7B in 2021 to $17.6B in 2026, about 15% a year.
After paying for its upkeep and new investment, it had $648.9M of cash to spare in the 12 months to Jul 2026.
What does management say it's aiming for?
Casey’s says its purpose is to make life better for communities and guests every day.
“To make life better for communities and guests every day.”
Who is responsible for the plan?
- Darren M. RebelezPresident and Chief Executive Officer
Oversees company performance and the allocation of resources and capital. Casey’s earns revenue primarily by selling fuel, prepared food, beverages and other merchandise through its convenience stores.
- Brad HagaSenior Vice President, Prepared Food and Dispensed Beverage
Leads the prepared food and dispensed beverage business. Prepared food and dispensed beverage sales include pizza, sandwiches, bakery products, coffee and fountain beverages.
- Doug MeansSenior Vice President, Chief Information Officer
Leads Casey’s information technology organization. Information technology supports Casey’s digital ordering, rewards platform and retail operations.
Roles checked November 11, 2026.
What management says it is working on now:
Grow food and beverage
Management plans to build the prepared-food business through made-to-order items such as pizza and wings, and expand its private-brand range.
Casey’s Announces New Three-Year Strategic PlanExpand the store base
The three-year plan calls for adding stores through acquisitions and new construction, extending Casey’s presence in current and new markets.
Casey’s Announces New Three-Year Strategic PlanImprove operating efficiency
Management is investing in technology and data tools to improve forecasting, food preparation, guest service and store operations.
Casey’s Announces New Three-Year Strategic PlanIntegrate and remodel acquired stores
Management said it was ahead of schedule integrating Fikes and expected to remodel CEFCO stores during fiscal 2027.
Casey's Q1 FY2027 Earnings Call Transcript
- Stores added, Over the three-year plan announced June 2026
- At least 400 stores
- Casey’s Announces New Three-Year Strategic Plan
What's changing right now?
Growth is picking up. In Q1 2027 it sold 24% more than a year earlier. The year before, quarters averaged 10%.
Since Oct 2026 the share price has risen 4%, from $677.09 to $705.72.
Recently
September 8, 2026
Inside same-store sales growth, fiscal Q1 changed to 3.2%
Q1 FY2027 resultsSeptember 8, 2026
Operating stores, July 31 changed to 2959 number
Q1 FY2027 store roll-forward
Coming up
Early fiscal 2027 third quarter
Expand chicken wing availability
Management said it planned to begin the next rollout tranche after the summer peak, with stores expected to start opening the offering early in fiscal 2027’s third quarter.
Casey's Q1 FY2027 Earnings Call TranscriptFiscal 2027, with results possibly inflecting in the fourth quarter
Remodel CEFCO stores
Management expected to remodel CEFCO stores through fiscal 2027 and said the benefits from the current remodeling cohort may become more visible later in the year.
Casey's Q1 FY2027 Earnings Call Transcript
Our own estimate moved too: the base case went from $239.42 to $208.90 a share between our last two valuations. The biggest reason: Operating stores, July 31 moved from an unreported prior value to 2959 number, as reported in Q1 FY2027 store roll-forward.
What could go wrong?
No business is a sure thing. These are the risks we found, starting with the ones the company itself names. Where a risk would change part of the valuation, it says which.
Fuel price and margin swings
Fuel makes up about 60% of revenue, and changes in wholesale prices, fuel demand or the margin per gallon can affect sales and profit. Management says these margins can vary significantly and unpredictably.
From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCasey's General Stores FY2026 Form 10-K
Strong retail competition
Casey’s competes with convenience stores, fuel retailers, supermarkets, restaurants and discount stores. Rivals with greater resources or more appealing prices and products could reduce its sales or profits.
From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCasey's General Stores FY2026 Form 10-K
Food costs and food safety
Higher costs for cheese, proteins, labor and transport may squeeze food profits if Casey’s cannot offset them. A food-safety incident could harm the brand, reduce demand and lead to claims or regulatory action.
From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCasey's General Stores FY2026 Form 10-K
Store growth and acquisition integration
Acquisitions and new stores can bring unexpected costs, hiring and systems challenges, and difficulty achieving planned improvements. These issues could slow growth or weigh on results.
From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCasey's General Stores FY2026 Form 10-K
Fuel demand may decline over time
More fuel-efficient vehicles, alternative fuels and changing driving habits could lower demand for gasoline. Fewer visits could also reduce sales of food and other store products.
From the company's own filingsWould hit its growth in the long runCasey's General Stores FY2026 Form 10-K
Cybersecurity and technology disruption
An attack or failure involving Casey’s systems or a technology provider could disrupt operations, expose sensitive data, lead to legal costs and damage guest trust.
From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCasey's General Stores FY2026 Form 10-K
Latest-quarter inside same-store sales slowed from 0.043 to 0.032.
From our researchWould hit how fast sales growQ1 FY2027 results
FY2025 acquisition cash payments exceeded $1.2 billion.
From our researchWould hit how much it has to reinvestFY2026 comparative cash-flow statement
Is it a good business?
From 2017 to 2026 it earned between 14% and 25% on its shareholders' equity, a median of 16%.
The number of shares has held roughly steady over the past year.
It owes $2B more than it holds in cash. An operating-profit comparison is unavailable from the published quarters.
What might it be worth?
The Valuation snapshot at the top of this page shows the answer. This is how we got there. A share is a slice of the business, so what a share is worth depends on what the business can earn for its owners from here on. We estimate that three ways, from cautious to hopeful, and call the result .
Today a share costs $705.72. Our put its value between $73.95 and $349.65, with $208.90 in the middle. Underneath sit two simpler checks: what it would cost to rebuild the business, its , and what today's profit is worth with no growth at all, its .
Bear case, $73.95
The recent sales surge fades as gasoline prices settle, while slower customer spending and costly expansion leave Casey's keeping less cash.
Base case, $208.90
Casey's grows more steadily after the recent sales surge, adding stores and selling more food while keeping spending under control.
Bull case, $349.65
Casey's builds on its recent growth by making new stores more productive and selling more food, allowing profits and cash to grow faster.
Another way in: instead of asking what the business is worth, ask what today's price assumes it will do.
Why the gap?
The price expects far more than we do.Price above value: 238%
For Caseys General Stores to be worth today's $705.72, sales would need to grow about 31.8% a year. We assume 5.0%. Over the last 5 years, sales grew 13.8% a year.
Or, if sales grow 5.0% as we assume, the price works with a profit margin of 18.2% (we assume 6.3%).
Keep in mind: investors are likely paying for things this model leaves out, such as new businesses or many more years of fast growth.
Do you think sales can grow 31.8% a year?
Try your own numbersWe're moderately sure of this range: it scores 50 out of 100 on our checks. The weakest point is terminal-value dependency.
Test the assumptions
Our base value of $208.90 rests on three assumptions. Change any of them to see how the value per share responds.
- Revenue growth, 5-year average5.0%
- Operating margin6.3%
- Long-term growth rate2.5%
This is an educational explanation built from public filings and our own research, not investment advice. It does not tell you whether to buy or sell anything.
Base estimate
$208.90 -70.4%


