CARVANA CO.

NYSE: CVNA·Tempe, Arizona·

Price
$70.74
Base IV
$21.98

Valuation snapshot

Above bull case

At $70.74, the price is above even our bull case of $40.67.

Values per share, from an .

No growth
…
Loading earnings power
Base case
$21.98
31% of the price · range $8.36–$40.67
Price vs base case
222% above
$70.74 against $21.98
Base casevalued by DCF
Price vs base
Priceclose 11‑16

The price has fallen 4.2% since this valuation was struck on 2026-11-12, so some of the gap opened up after these figures were set.

Whisker on the base case runs bear $8.36 to bull $40.67. Values per share.

Price against each value

Bear case
$8.36
Price 746% above
No growth
…
—
Base case
$21.98
Price 222% above
Researched byClaude Opus 5.5
Valuation Nov 12, 2026 · Price as of Nov 16, 2026How we got here

What does Carvana do?

Carvana provides an e-commerce platform for consumers to buy and sell used cars online, offering remote vehicle inspections, automated trade-in offers, and integrated financing.

It brought in $27.5B of sales in the 12 months to Sep 2026.

Led by Ernest C. Garcia III, President, Chief Executive Officer and Chairman. Carvana Co. 2026 Definitive Proxy Statement (DEF 14A)

ADESA Clear online vehicle marketplaceImage: ADESA
Industry
Consumer discretionary
Based in
Tempe, Arizona
Trades on
NYSE as CVNA

Here is where each dollar a customer pays ends up. Out of every $1 of sales in the 12 months to Sep 2026, about 6¢ was left as profit after every cost, interest and tax. The biggest cost is making what it sells, 81¢ of every dollar.

  • Making what it sells81¢
  • Sales, marketing and admin10¢
  • Interest and other costs12¢
  • Left as profit6¢
  • Tax credit came back in+10¢
Totals of the four quarters to Sep 2026, from the company's own filings. The split by product is from the latest fiscal year.

Who pays Carvana, and for what?

Carvana sells used cars through an online marketplace, with delivery or pickup options. It earns revenue from vehicle sales, wholesale sales, loan sales and commissions on add-on products such as service contracts, GAP coverage and insurance.

Consumers buy cars and related products from Carvana, while vehicle sellers and wholesale marketplace participants also pay fees or transact through its platform.

  • Retail vehicle sales

    72%

    Sales of vehicles to customers through Carvana's website, including delivery fees and some marketplace partner transactions.

  • Wholesale sales and revenues

    20%

    Sales of trade-ins and other acquired vehicles to wholesalers, plus fees and services from its wholesale marketplace.

    ADESA Clear online vehicle marketplaceImage: ADESA
  • Other sales and revenues

    9%

    Mainly proceeds from selling loans originated for car purchases and commissions on service contracts, GAP coverage and auto insurance.

Share of the latest fiscal year's sales, as the company reports it.

Where its work physically happens, beyond headquarters:

  • ADESA Golden Gate — Tracy, United States. This more than 150-acre auction site supports wholesale operations and expanded vehicle reconditioning capacity for the Bay Area.
  • ADESA Boston — Framingham, United States. Its more than 100 acres and 13,000 parking spaces support a regional vehicle inventory pool, wholesale auctions, and reconditioning capacity.
  • ADESA Atlanta — Fairburn, United States. This more than 100-acre site combines wholesale auctions with added reconditioning capacity and a retail inventory pool for the Atlanta region.
  • ADESA Indianapolis — Plainfield, United States. The more than 100-acre auction site provides space for vehicle inspection, reconditioning, and a regional retail inventory pool.
  • ADESA Syracuse — Cicero, United States. This approximately 150-acre wholesale auction site is being equipped for retail vehicle reconditioning and fulfillment in Central New York.
See them on the globe

Carvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

How is the business doing?

Sales grew from $5.6B in 2020 to $20.3B in 2025, about 29% a year.

Running the business leaves about 9¢ of each sales dollar as operating profit, up from 1¢ in 2023.

After paying for its upkeep and new investment, it had $1.1B of cash to spare in the 12 months to Sep 2026.

Sales$20.3B
20172025
Operating margin9%
20172025
Free cash flow$889M
20172025
Each bar is one fiscal year (2017–2025), summed from four published quarters; the latest is highlighted.

What does management say it's aiming for?

Carvana says it exists to change how people buy cars.

“change the way people buy cars”

Carvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

Who is responsible for the plan?

Roles checked November 12, 2026.

What management says it is working on now:

  • Grow retail sales efficiently

    Management says retail vehicle sales remain its main long-term measure, with a focus on efficient growth while continuing to improve profitability.

    Carvana Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter
  • Expand vehicle supply and reconditioning

    Management says growth depends on increasing vehicle production capacity, including investment in reconditioning sites, staffing, processes and systems.

    Carvana Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter
  • Improve customer experience and awareness

    Management identifies better customer experience, stronger brand awareness and trust, and broader vehicle selection as key drivers of growth.

    Carvana Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter
  • Use infrastructure and technology more effectively

    Management says it is improving efficiency through technology, process changes and fuller use of its logistics and reconditioning network.

    Carvana Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter
Adjusted EBITDA, Full-year 2026
$2.7–$3.0 billion, with results expected toward the higher end
Carvana Announces Record Third Quarter 2026 Results
Retail units sold, Between 2030 and 2035
3 million annually
Carvana Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter
Operating margin, Between 2030 and 2035
12.5%
Carvana Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter
Goals in management's own numbers. A target is a promise, not a result.

What's changing right now?

Growth is slowing. In Q3 2026 it sold 42% more than a year earlier. The year before, quarters averaged 54%.

Its operating margin is about where it was a year ago, 9¢ per sales dollar.

Since Oct 2026 the share price has risen 4%, from $68.31 to $70.74.

Bull $40.67Base $21.98Bear $8.36Oct 30Nov 16 · $70.74
Daily closing prices we have recorded, set against our bear-to-bull range. Our price records start October 30, 2026.

Recently

Coming up

  • Q4 2026; results date not yet scheduled

    Fourth-quarter 2026 results

    Carvana expects retail units sold to rise sequentially in Q4 and adjusted EBITDA to be toward the high end of its full-year range, assuming conditions remain stable.

    Carvana Announces Record Third Quarter 2026 Results

Our own estimate moved too: the base case went from $23.96 to $21.98 a share between our last two valuations.

What could go wrong?

No business is a sure thing. These are the risks we found, starting with the ones the company itself names. Where a risk would change part of the valuation, it says which.

  1. Competition and vehicle pricing

    Carvana competes with dealerships, online marketplaces and private sellers. Price changes can affect customer demand, the value of its inventory and the profit it makes when reselling cars.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

  2. Consumer and economic conditions

    Car purchases can fall when household budgets are strained. Higher interest rates can make monthly payments less affordable and reduce demand.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

  3. Inventory sourcing and resale

    Carvana depends on finding enough desirable vehicles and selling them quickly. Too much inventory or a drop in used-car prices could force lower selling prices and reduce profits.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

  4. Regulatory requirements

    Vehicle sales, financing, delivery and add-on products are subject to changing federal, state and local rules. Violations or new requirements could increase costs, limit sales or affect licenses.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCarvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

  5. Debt and access to financing

    Carvana has substantial debt and relies on financing to support operations and vehicle inventory. Higher borrowing costs or limited access to funding could constrain its plans and increase expenses.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCarvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

  6. Customer service and reputation

    The business depends on customers trusting its online buying and selling process. Problems with vehicle quality, paperwork or delivery could hurt that trust and reduce demand.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarvana Co. 2025 Form 10-K

  7. Part of the 2025 revenue growth came from booking certain marketplace-partner vehicles at gross revenue, which will stop flattering year-over-year growth once it laps.

    From our researchWould hit how fast sales growCarvana Q4/FY2025 results release

  8. Adjusted EBITDA margin fell to 10.4% in Q2 2026 from 12.4% a year earlier.

    From our researchWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCarvana Q2 2026 results release

Is it a good business?

From 2017 to 2025 it earned between -117% and 185% on its shareholders' equity, a median of -44%.

Over 3 years its operating margin ranged from 1¢ to 9¢ per sales dollar, a median of 7¢. Gross margin ran from 8¢ to 21¢.

derived computed from the filingsassumption cost of capital from the latest valuation
Return on equity41%
20172025
Return on invested capital is operating profit after tax (at the median effective rate, —) over debt plus equity less cash at each fiscal year end. Return on equity is net income over equity. Both are computed from published quarters.

The number of shares has held roughly steady over the past year.

It owes $2.3B more than it holds in cash, about 1.0 years of operating profit.

What might it be worth?

The Valuation snapshot at the top of this page shows the answer. This is how we got there. A share is a slice of the business, so what a share is worth depends on what the business can earn for its owners from here on. We estimate that three ways, from cautious to hopeful, and call the result .

Today a share costs $70.74. Our put its value between $8.36 and $40.67, with $21.98 in the middle. Underneath sit two simpler checks: what it would cost to rebuild the business, its , and what today's profit is worth with no growth at all, its .

Bear case, $8.36

This scenario assumes Carvana's rapid sales growth of the last two years, about 40% to 50% a year, slows sharply as higher interest rates and fuel costs hurt used-car buyers, and that profit per car keeps slipping as it did through 2026.

Base case, $21.98

This scenario assumes Carvana keeps taking market share from traditional dealers, so sales growth eases from about 40% today toward the low teens over five years, and profits per sale stay close to their recent levels.

Bull case, $40.67

This scenario assumes Carvana keeps growing close to its recent pace of roughly 40% more cars sold each year for a while longer and moves toward management's goal of 3 million cars a year with higher profit on each sale.

Another way in: instead of asking what the business is worth, ask what today's price assumes it will do.

Why the gap?

The price expects far more than we do.Price above value: 222%

For Carvana to be worth today's $70.74, sales would need to grow about 49.9% a year. We assume 18.2%. Over the last 5 years, sales grew 20.3% a year.

−20%0%+20%+40%+60%We assume 18.2%Past 5 yrs 20.3%Price needs 49.9%

Or, if sales grow 18.2% as we assume, the price works with a profit margin of 26.8% (we assume 9.5%).

Keep in mind: investors are likely paying for things this model leaves out, such as new businesses or many more years of fast growth.

Do you think sales can grow 49.9% a year?

Try your own numbers

We're not very sure of this range: it scores 48 out of 100 on our checks. The weakest point is historical stability.

Test the assumptions

Our base value of $21.98 rests on three assumptions. Change any of them to see how the value per share responds.

  • Revenue growth, 5-year average18.2%

    Next year 32.0%, then about 15%

  • Operating margin9.5%
  • Long-term growth rate3.0%

This is an educational explanation built from public filings and our own research, not investment advice. It does not tell you whether to buy or sell anything.

Base estimate

$21.98 -68.9%

Build