CARMAX INC

NYSE: KMX·Richmond, Virginia·

Price
$51.65
Base IV
-$39.32

Valuation snapshot

Above bull case

At $51.65, the price is above even our bull case of $21.26.

Values per share, from an .

Price against each value

Bear case
-$81.28
—
No growth
…
—
Base case
-$39.32
—
Researched byClaude Opus 5.5
Valuation Nov 13, 2026 · Price as of Nov 16, 2026How we got here

What does Carmax do?

CarMax sells used vehicles and provides auto financing and inspection services to help consumers purchase and sell cars through a standardized, no-haggle retail process.

It brought in $27.6B of sales in the 12 months to Aug 2026.

Led by Keith Barr, President and Chief Executive Officer since 2026. CarMax Inc. Form 8-K (February 2026): CEO transition, appointment of Keith Barr

Industry
Consumer discretionary
Based in
Richmond, Virginia
Trades on
NYSE as KMX

Here is where each dollar a customer pays ends up. Out of every $1 of sales in the 12 months to Aug 2026, about 1¢ was left as profit after every cost, interest and tax. The biggest cost is making what it sells, 90¢ of every dollar.

  • Making what it sells90¢
  • Sales, marketing and admin9¢
  • Tax1¢
  • Left as profit1¢
Totals of the four quarters to Aug 2026, from the company's own filings. The split by product is from the latest fiscal year.

Who pays Carmax, and for what?

CarMax is the largest used-car retailer in the US. It buys cars from consumers and dealers, fixes them up and sells them at set, no-haggle prices online and in 256 stores. It also sells older trade-ins to dealers at its own auctions, makes car loans through its finance arm, and earns fees from extended warranties and the Edmunds car-shopping website.

Mainly individual consumers buying, selling or financing used cars, plus licensed car dealers who buy vehicles at CarMax auctions and sell cars to CarMax through its MaxOffer service.

  • Used vehicle sales

    80%

    Retail sales of inspected and reconditioned used cars, mostly 0 to 10 years old, sold at no-haggle prices online, in stores or through a mix of both. CarMax sold 780,684 cars this way in fiscal 2026.

  • Wholesale vehicle sales

    17%

    Older, higher-mileage cars that do not meet CarMax's retail standards are sold to licensed dealers at CarMax's own auctions, which are now mostly held online. 538,203 vehicles were sold in fiscal 2026.

  • Extended protection plans

    2%

    Commissions for selling extended service plans and GAP coverage (which pays off a loan if the car is totalled) on behalf of outside insurers. About 52% of retail buyers bought a service plan.

  • Advertising and subscriptions (Edmunds)

    1%

    Revenue from Edmunds, the online car research and shopping site CarMax bought in 2021. Edmunds earns money from advertising and from subscriptions sold to dealers.

  • Service and other

    0%

    Mainly vehicle repair work done in CarMax store service departments, including repairs covered by the service plans it sells.

  • CarMax Auto Finance (CAF)

    CarMax's own lender makes car loans only to its own customers and financed 42.4% of retail cars sold. It earned $562.7 million of income in fiscal 2026. This income is reported separately, not as part of sales revenue.

Share of the latest fiscal year's sales, as the company reports it.

Where its work physically happens, beyond headquarters:

  • CarMax Auto Finance office — Atlanta, United States. The Atlanta office houses CarMax Auto Finance, which reported $562.7 million in fiscal 2026 income from its vehicle financing business.
  • Frederick reconditioning and auction center — Frederick, United States. This center supports the Washington, D.C., and Baltimore markets by adding vehicle reconditioning and auction capacity.
  • Midlothian reconditioning and auction center — Midlothian, United States. This center supports the Dallas market, adding capacity that helps CarMax balance reconditioning and auction activity across its stores.
  • El Mirage reconditioning and auction center — El Mirage, United States. This center supports the Phoenix market with vehicle reconditioning and auction capacity outside CarMax's stores.
  • Locust Grove reconditioning and auction center — Locust Grove, United States. Opened in fiscal 2027, this center adds reconditioning and auction capacity for the Atlanta market.
See them on the globe

CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

How is the business doing?

Sales grew from $19B in 2021 to $25.9B in 2026, about 6% a year.

After paying for its upkeep and new investment, it had $1.1B of cash to spare in the 12 months to Aug 2026.

Sales$25.9B
20172026
Free cash flow$1.2B
20172026
Each bar is one fiscal year (2017–2026), summed from four published quarters; the latest is highlighted.

What does management say it's aiming for?

CarMax says its purpose is to act with integrity by being honest and open with customers in every interaction.

“to drive integrity by being honest and transparent in every interaction”

CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

Who is responsible for the plan?

Roles checked November 13, 2026.

What management says it is working on now:

  • The 'Shift into GEAR' turnaround plan

    New CEO Keith Barr is running a four-part plan to strengthen the core business and get the company growing again. The four parts are a great offering, an easy experience, adding value and running lean.

    CarMax Reports Second Quarter Fiscal 2027 Results (Form 8-K)
  • Lower prices to win back sales

    Management wants CarMax to be the obvious choice by offering a fair price, a broad selection and an easy experience. It has cut prices and is accepting less profit per car to improve sales, after its market share slipped in late 2025.

    CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
  • Cut operating costs

    CarMax is cutting overhead costs, including a roughly 30% reduction in its customer call-center staff, and is lowering the cost of moving and reconditioning cars. The savings are meant to fund lower prices and lift earnings.

    CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
  • Use technology and AI in practical ways

    Management plans to use software, data and AI to make buying and selling cars easier for customers and to make staff more efficient. Examples include the Skye virtual assistant and online checkout.

    CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
  • Lend to more types of borrowers

    CarMax Auto Finance is building the ability to lend to customers across the full credit range, including people with weaker credit who are now mostly served by outside lenders. The aim is to keep more of the financing profit and support car sales.

    CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
Yearly overhead cost savings (SG&A, run rate), By the end of fiscal 2027 (February 2027)
$200 million
CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
Extended protection plan profit per car sold, Fiscal 2027
Increase of about $35 per car
CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
Tier 2 loans made by CarMax Auto Finance, By the end of fiscal 2027
Nearly $1 billion
CarMax (KMX) Q2 2027 Earnings Call Transcript
New store openings, Fiscal 2027
4 stores, plus 2 reconditioning/auction centers and 2 stand-alone auction sites
CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026
Goals in management's own numbers. A target is a promise, not a result.

What's changing right now?

Growth is picking up. In Q2 2027 it sold 19% more than a year earlier. The year before, quarters averaged -2%.

Since Oct 2026 the share price has fallen 8%, from $56.17 to $51.65.

Bull $21.26Base -$39.32Bear -$81.28Oct 30Nov 16 · $51.65
Daily closing prices we have recorded, set against our bear-to-bull range. Our price records start October 30, 2026.

Recently

Coming up

  • November 3, 2026, 8:00 a.m. ET

    Strategic Update for investors

    CarMax will hold an online Strategic Update. Management says it will give details on its growth strategy, key initiatives and milestones, which may include new long-term goals.

    CarMax Reports Second Quarter Fiscal 2027 Results (Form 8-K)
  • Fiscal Q3 2027 (September to November 2026)

    Share buybacks restart

    CarMax paused buying back its own shares in early 2026 because its borrowing was above its target range. It said it plans to start buybacks again this quarter.

    CarMax Reports Second Quarter Fiscal 2027 Results (Form 8-K)
  • Expected mid-to-late December 2026 (not yet confirmed)

    Third-quarter fiscal 2027 results

    The next quarterly report will show whether the recent sales rebound continues and how the cost-saving plan is going. CarMax has not confirmed a date; last year's equivalent report came out on December 18.

    CarMax Investor Relations news
  • By end of February 2027

    Cost-savings goal deadline

    Management aims to reach $200 million in yearly overhead savings by the end of fiscal 2027, with the full benefit expected in fiscal 2028.

    CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

Our own estimate moved too: the base case went from $42.87 to -$39.32 a share between our last two valuations. The biggest reason: Retail gross profit per used unit, quarterly moved from an unreported prior value to $2.1K, as reported in CarMax Q2 FY2027 results.

What could go wrong?

No business is a sure thing. These are the risks we found, starting with the ones the company itself names. Where a risk would change part of the valuation, it says which.

  1. Strong competition, including online sellers

    Used-car selling is crowded, with franchised dealers, online platforms and private sellers competing for buyers. Some rivals copy CarMax's no-haggle model. CarMax's national market share fell from 3.7% to 3.6% in 2025.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

  2. Economy and car affordability

    Car sales depend on jobs, interest rates, gas prices, tariffs and how confident shoppers feel. When cars or monthly payments get more expensive, fewer people can afford to buy, and sales and profits can fall.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

  3. Borrowers not repaying car loans

    CarMax's own lender holds about $16.4 billion of car loans. If more borrowers stop paying, especially as it lends to people with weaker credit, losses could exceed the amount CarMax has set aside for them.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

  4. Dependence on borrowing markets

    CarMax funds most of its car loans by bundling them and selling them to investors. If that market becomes costly or shuts down, CarMax might have to cut back its lending, which could hurt sales.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

  5. Falling profit per car and inventory value

    Used cars lose value while they sit in inventory, and price swings can squeeze profit. Management chose to lower prices, and profit per used car fell in fiscal 2026 and again in the August 2026 quarter.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how much of each sale it keepsCarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

  6. Leadership change and turnaround execution

    CarMax replaced its CEO in late 2025, and Keith Barr took over in March 2026. Layoffs and restructuring could hurt morale or the company culture. Profit fell about half in fiscal 2026, partly due to a $141 million write-down.

    From the company's own filingsWould hit how fast sales growCarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended Feb 28, 2026

  7. The gains were supported by pricing actions that lowered per-unit gross profit, so they may not last.

    From our researchWould hit how fast sales growCarMax Q2 FY2027 results

Is it a good business?

From 2017 to 2026 it earned between 4% and 25% on its shareholders' equity, a median of 19%.

derived computed from the filingsassumption cost of capital from the latest valuation
Return on equity4%
20172026
Return on invested capital is operating profit after tax (at the median effective rate, 25%) over debt plus equity less cash at each fiscal year end. Return on equity is net income over equity. Both are computed from published quarters.

It bought back shares: the count fell 4.8% in a year, so each remaining share owns a slightly bigger slice.

It owes $17.4B more than it holds in cash. An operating-profit comparison is unavailable from the published quarters.

What might it be worth?

The Valuation snapshot at the top of this page shows the answer. This is how we got there. A share is a slice of the business, so what a share is worth depends on what the business can earn for its owners from here on. We estimate that three ways, from cautious to hopeful, and call the result .

Today a share costs $51.65. Our put its value between -$81.28 and $21.26, with -$39.32 in the middle. Underneath sit two simpler checks: what it would cost to rebuild the business, its , and what today's profit is worth with no growth at all, its .

Bear case, -$81.28

This scenario assumes CarMax's recent sales rebound fades once its price cuts stop drawing extra buyers, leaving a business that grows slowly and earns thin profits, much like its weak last three years.

Base case, -$39.32

This scenario assumes CarMax keeps much of its recent sales rebound after three years of shrinking, growing at a moderate pace while profits recover slightly from today's thin levels.

Bull case, $21.26

This scenario assumes CarMax's sharp recent jump in car sales keeps going and its profits climb back toward the healthier levels it earned before 2022.

Another way in: instead of asking what the business is worth, ask what today's price assumes it will do.

Why the gap?

The price expects far more than we do.

For Carmax to be worth today's $51.65, sales would need to grow about 21.8% a year. We assume 4.0%. Over the last 5 years, sales grew 1.2% a year.

−5%0%+5%+10%+15%+20%+25%Past 5 yrs 1.2%We assume 4.0%Price needs 21.8%

Or, if sales grow 4.0% as we assume, the price works with a profit margin of 7.3% (we assume 3.5%).

Keep in mind: investors are likely paying for things this model leaves out, such as new businesses or many more years of fast growth.

Do you think sales can grow 21.8% a year?

Try your own numbers

We're moderately sure of this range: it scores 52 out of 100 on our checks. The weakest point is scenario dispersion.

Test the assumptions

Our base value of -$39.32 rests on three assumptions. Change any of them to see how the value per share responds.

  • Revenue growth, 5-year average4.0%
  • Operating margin3.5%
  • Long-term growth rate2.5%

This is an educational explanation built from public filings and our own research, not investment advice. It does not tell you whether to buy or sell anything.

Base estimate

-$39.32 -176.1%

Build