Methodology
Every valuation is a story told in numbers
Why a valuation needs a story behind its inputs, the few numbers every business story comes down to, and why a smaller story can be worth more than a bigger one.
Stories and spreadsheets
Aswath Damodaran's book Narrative and Numbers starts from a split many investors will recognize. Some people think in stories: what the company does, who its customers are, why it will win. Others think in numbers: growth rates, margins, discount rates. Each approach, used alone, goes wrong in a predictable way.
A story without numbers can promise anything, because nothing checks it. A spreadsheet without a story has the opposite problem: its inputs look precise, but nobody can say why they are what they are. A useful valuation has both. Every number has a reason, and every part of the story has a number.
What a story comes down to
However detailed the story, it affects value through a handful of inputs. StockValuer's DCF uses these inputs. My valuation asks you about four of them, growth, margin, risk and long-run growth. Reinvestment starts from StockValuer's research, and you can change it on the Tax and reinvestment row:
- How big the market is and how much of it the company wins, which sets revenue growth.
- Why the business earns what it does, which sets the operating margin.
- What growth costs in new investment, which sets reinvestment.
- How uncertain all of this is, which sets the discount rate.
- How long the business can keep growing, which sets long-run growth.
A small story can be worth more
One of the book's examples is Ferrari. The obvious growth story, selling many more cars, sounds bigger. But Ferrari's value rests on exclusivity: selling few cars at very high margins to buyers who are willing to wait. Selling many more cars would weaken the thing that lets it charge those prices. Valued carefully, the small, exclusive story is worth more than the big one.
The same applies to any business. Before you choose a growth rate, ask what the business is, and whether faster growth fits that story or works against it.
Writing yours down
When you build a valuation in StockValuer, each assumption is one part of your story expressed as a number. The What must hold list under a saved valuation is the story in words: the statements that must be true for your numbers to be right. With both saved, you can check later which parts of the story the results support.
Terms in this guide