Methodology

Possible, plausible, probable: testing your assumptions

Three questions to ask of any forecast, and how StockValuer compares each assumption you make with the company's own record and its peers.

Three tests

Narrative and Numbers suggests asking three questions of every part of a story. Each is harder to pass than the one before:

  • Possible: could it happen at all? Revenue larger than the whole market fails this test.
  • Plausible: is there evidence it can happen? Margins no comparable business has ever reached are possible but not yet plausible.
  • Probable: is it already showing up in the results? A claimed advantage that never appears in margins or growth is not yet probable.

How StockValuer labels your assumptions

As you set growth, margin, long-run growth, tax and reinvestment in My valuation, a line under your value tells you what the filings show about your choice. The labels say what was checked, not how likely your assumption is:

  • Within its track record: inside the range the company itself has reported over its recent fiscal years.
  • Below its track record: lower than any year it has reported.
  • Peers have done this: beyond the company's own record, but within what its peers have reported.
  • Higher than it has ever achieved: beyond both. The assumption depends on the company doing better than it ever has.
  • For long-run growth: in line with the economy when it is at or below the risk-free rate, and faster than the economy when it is above. A business growing faster than the economy forever would eventually be bigger than the economy.

What the labels are for

An assumption marked Higher than it has ever achieved is not necessarily a mistake. Every company that changed its industry did something it had never done before. The label tells you when your valuation depends on that kind of change, so you can decide how much of it you believe.