Methodology

Reading results against your thesis

When a company reports, check what the results did to your story: shifted it, changed it or broke it. This guide shows how the What must hold list helps.

Story first, price second

On a results day, the price move gets the most attention. Narrative and Numbers suggests asking a different question first: what did these results do to the story behind my valuation?

Shifted, changed or broken

Damodaran sorts the effect of news into three kinds:

  • A shift: the story holds and the details move. Growth is a little slower, or margins a point lower. Adjust the inputs.
  • A change: the story is materially different, such as a new market, or an advantage that is weaker than you thought. Rebuild the valuation.
  • A break: the story no longer holds, because of a lost licence, a failed product or a broken business model. The valuation built on it no longer applies.

What the What must hold list does

Under a saved valuation, What must hold lists the statements your numbers depend on: your thesis, in words. It suggests statements to start from, drawn from the choices you made and from the company's main business drivers. Press a suggestion to track it, or choose Add your own. Each statement starts as Not checked. Press it to change its wording, its status, the number it tests, and your notes and sources.

Once the company reports after your valuation, the list compares its last twelve months with the numbers you chose. Revenue growth is compared with your first forecast year, with a stated tolerance either side. Operating margin is judged by direction: has it moved toward your target since you valued the company, or away from it?

If a statement tests one of those numbers, its row shows the comparison and the status it points to, such as Mark at risk. Nothing changes until you press the button, and Not now sets the suggestion aside until the next quarter is reported. The list never marks a statement broken. Deciding that a story is broken is always your call.