Methodology
Why a bad day rarely changes value
Prices move every day. What a business is worth changes much less often. This guide shows how to tell a move that changes value from one that only changes price.
Price and value are different things
A share's price is what the last buyer and seller agreed on. Its value is what the business will pay its owners over the years: the cash it earns, discounted back to today. The price changes every second. The value changes only when something changes those future cash flows, or the rate they are discounted at.
On most days, nothing like that happens. A stock that falls 2% along with the rest of the market has the same customers, products and costs it had the day before.
The arithmetic behind it
Most of a company's value comes from the cash it earns years from now. One day is a tiny slice of a business's life, so news that affects only the next quarter moves the value very little, even when it moves the price a lot.
For the value to fall 8%, the long-run cash flows have to fall by about that much, or the discount rate has to rise. Some news does that. Most daily news does not.
Moves that can change value
Each market report sorts its biggest movers into price, value or unclear. Unclear means the news does not settle it. A move is marked value when the news changes what the business is likely to earn:
- A profit forecast cut or raised, especially for more than the next quarter.
- A deal, a lost customer, a new product or a court ruling that changes future sales or costs.
- Results that show the business is earning noticeably more or less than expected, on margins or on growth.
- A lasting change in interest rates, which changes the discount rate for every company at once.
Moves that usually change only price
- The whole market or the whole sector moving together on one day's headlines.
- A fall or rise with no news about the business itself.
- Funds buying or selling large blocks for their own reasons, such as a change in an index's members.
What to do with a big move
Ask what the news did to the story behind your valuation: did it shift a detail, change the story or break it? If nothing about future cash flows changed, only the gap between price and value has moved. If something did change, revisit the assumptions it affects, and base your view on the new value, not the new price.