Methodology

Where these ideas come from

StockValuer applies ideas from four value investors and teachers. Here is what each idea is, where you meet it on a company's page, and where to read more.

Price and value are different: Benjamin Graham

Graham taught that a share is part of a business, and that its price and its value are different things. The price is what the market offers today. The value is what the business is worth, worked out from its own figures. He asked investors to pay well under that value, so that a mistake in the estimate would not be costly. He called that cushion the margin of safety.

He also described the market as a moody business partner who names a new price every day, sometimes far too high and sometimes far too low. You can ignore the offer, or take it when it suits you. His name for that partner, Mr. Market, is still widely used.

Where you see it: the margin of safety on a company's Overview and in the screener, and the market report, which sorts each big move into price, value or unclear.

Read more: The Intelligent Investor, especially the chapters on market fluctuations and on margin of safety, and Security Analysis, written with David Dodd.

Owning a business: Warren Buffett

Buffett, Graham's student, put the weight on the business itself. Before you ask what a company is worth, ask whether it is a good business: does it earn well on the capital it uses, and what stops competitors from taking those returns away? He calls that protection a moat. He also argued for staying with businesses you understand well enough to explain.

His measure of what a business earns for its owners is owner earnings: profit, plus depreciation, minus the capital spending needed to keep the business as competitive as it is. He set it out in his 1986 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders.

Where you see it: the “Is it a good business?” chapter on a company's Overview, the franchise figure beside the Assets line in the Valuation snapshot, and the Overview's first chapter, which asks what the company does.

Read more: his letters to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, which Berkshire publishes free on its website.

Value in layers: Bruce Greenwald

Greenwald, who taught value investing at Columbia Business School, values a business in three layers. Asset value comes first: what it would cost to rebuild the business. Earnings power comes next: what today's sustainable profit is worth with no growth. Growth comes last. Each layer rests on more assumptions than the one before it, so you can see how much of a price depends on the riskiest part.

When earnings power is well above asset value, the gap is franchise value, and something must be keeping competitors out. He argues that growth only adds value behind that kind of barrier. Without one, new investment earns only its cost.

Where you see it: the Valuation snapshot at the top of a company's Overview, where it draws No growth, Growth and Base case as a bridge to the price, with Assets as a line inside the No growth bar, and the way StockValuer splits capital spending into maintenance and growth.

Read more: Value Investing: From Graham to Buffett and Beyond, and Competition Demystified.

A story told in numbers: Aswath Damodaran

Damodaran, who teaches corporate finance and valuation at NYU Stern, argues that every valuation is a story about a business expressed as numbers. Each input should have a reason you can state, and each part of the story should show up in an input. He tests a story by asking whether it is possible, plausible and probable, and sorts later news by whether it shifts, changes or breaks the story.

Where you see it: the blue numbers in My valuation, the labels that compare each of your assumptions with the company's record and its peers, and the What must hold list under a saved valuation. The equity risk premium in the discount rate is cited to its source on each valuation; by default that is the implied premium he publishes.

Read more: Narrative and Numbers. He also publishes his data, classes and valuation spreadsheets free online.

What StockValuer adds, and what it does not claim

StockValuer reads each company's figures from its SEC filings, researches the forward assumptions with citations, and lays out every step, so these habits are quick to apply to any company it covers. The choices of method, ranges and defaults are StockValuer's own.

None of these four people is involved with StockValuer or has reviewed it. The ideas are theirs; any mistakes in applying them are ours.